What is a collagen matrix for soft tissue reconstruction?

By Puredent Team Published October 27, 202613 min read
Short answer

A collagen matrix for soft tissue augmentation is a resorbable scaffold of purified collagen, typically from porcine sources, that can be used instead of a connective tissue graft from the palate for recession coverage and gingival thickening. In meta-analyses, connective tissue grafts provide greater root coverage, but the matrix spares the patient an additional surgical site, and it is not limited by how much tissue the palate can provide when multiple recessions need to be covered.1, 2, 6

What is a collagen matrix?

Autologous connective tissue graft remains the reference treatment for recession coverage, including in a meta-analysis of 16 randomized trials published by Koppolu et al. in Medicina in 2026.2 But what should be done when multiple recessions need to be covered, or the patient wishes to avoid tissue harvesting from the palate? A porcine collagen matrix may be an option.

A collagen matrix is a soft tissue replacement material made of purified collagen that is placed under the gingiva to cover exposed root surfaces, increase tissue thickness, or increase the width of keratinized tissue. It is used instead of an autologous connective tissue graft, which would otherwise be harvested from the palate.1 The disadvantage of the graft is the additional surgical site. Dadlani describes in a narrative review in the International Journal of Dentistry that harvesting from the palate causes more postoperative pain, carries a risk of bleeding, and requires a longer procedure, and that the amount of tissue is limited when multiple recessions need to be covered.1 This is where a collagen matrix may be an option. What the studies show for the mucoderm porcine matrix is described in the section on mucoderm.

How does a collagen matrix work in soft tissue augmentation?

The matrix is acellular and functions as a three-dimensional scaffold for tissue ingrowth. It provides mechanical support, stabilizes the blood clot, and provides cells with a structure to attach to and migrate into, as described by Elbana et al. in a randomized trial involving 40 patients in BMC Oral Health.3

In laboratory and animal studies reviewed by Dadlani, a porcine dermal matrix increased the growth and proliferation of gingival fibroblasts, osteoblasts, and endothelial cells. The author interprets this as a sign of early revascularization, but these are not clinical outcome measures.1

Precisely because the matrix is acellular, the authors of the Koppolu analysis assess that it may become vascularized and remodeled to a lesser extent than a connective tissue graft, which may explain why the results after 12 months are slightly worse than those with a connective tissue graft.2

What types of collagen matrix and acellular dermal matrix are available?

Soft tissue replacements can be broadly divided into three groups:

  • Xenogene collagen matrix made of porcine collagen, composed of layers of collagen fibers with a porous layer that promotes blood clot formation and tissue ingrowth from the surrounding area, as described by Panda et al. in a network meta-analysis in Clinical and Experimental Dental Research.2, 6
  • Porcine acellular dermal matrix, in which the dermis from pigs has been cleared of cells, non-collagenous proteins, bacteria, and viruses. What remains is a three-dimensional matrix of type I and III collagen and elastin that is not chemically cross-linked.1
  • Allogene acellular dermal matrix made from human skin. Dadlani describes that it is subject to ethical concerns and restrictions in many European countries, which has increased the use of porcine materials.1

The two porcine types are not necessarily identical in clinical practice. Koppolu et al. analyzed the two porcine types separately and point out that a previous meta-analysis that combined them yielded more heterogeneous results.2

What is a collagen matrix used for in soft tissue augmentation?

Recession coverage with a coronally advanced flap

Collagen matrices have been particularly studied for gingival recessions, where the matrix is placed under a coronally advanced flap (CAF). All biomaterials used as a supplement to CAF performed better than CAF alone, and connective tissue graft ranked highest for both root coverage and the width of keratinized tissue. This was found by Panda et al. in a network meta-analysis of 39 randomized trials with at least 12 months of follow-up, 19 of which were included in the network analysis itself, for Miller class I and II recessions. The evidence was assessed as moderate, and the risk of bias was high in most comparisons.6

For multiple recessions, connective tissue graft provided significantly greater average root coverage than both porcine materials after 12 months in the Koppolu analysis (16 randomized trials, 632 patients, 1878 recessions), while there was no statistically significant difference in pocket depth. The authors call the xenogene materials a promising alternative, especially when patient comfort is prioritized. According to them, pain was lower with the replacement material in each of the trials, but the measurements could not be pooled statistically because the trials used different scales and time points.2

Clinically, the choice therefore involves weighing the greater average root coverage after 12 months with a connective tissue graft against the possibility of avoiding an additional surgical site by using a porcine matrix. The results for mucoderm, which was included in eight of the 16 trials, are described further down.2

Platelet concentrates such as platelet-rich fibrin (PRF) have also been studied for recession coverage, both with CAF and with tunnel techniques.5, 6 Read more in the article What is PRF?

Tunnel technique and VISTA

In the tunnel technique, the gingiva is loosened through sulcular incisions without vertical releasing incisions, and the matrix or graft is inserted into a tunnel under the tissue, so that the papillae and blood supply are preserved.3, 4 A meta-analysis by Mayta-Tovalino et al. in the International Journal of Dentistry found no statistically significant difference in root coverage between tunnel technique and CAF after 6 months. The total of five randomized trials with 173 patients, four of whom had acellular dermal matrix, and the quality of evidence was very low. Previous meta-analyses, which both Mayta-Tovalino et al. and Koppolu et al. discuss, found better results with CAF than with tunnel technique when a replacement material was used.2, 4

Clinically, the current evidence therefore cannot determine whether tunnel technique or CAF provides greater root coverage with a matrix. According to Mayta-Tovalino et al., tunnel technique requires additional training and special instruments.4 For intrasulcular incisions and tunneling, angled spoon blades such as MJK spoon blades SB002 and other microsurgical blades are used.

VISTA (vestibular incision subperiosteal tunnel access) is a variant of the tunnel technique, where access is achieved through a vertical incision in the vestibule, and the gingiva is loosened subperiosteally and advanced coronally. Zhu et al. describe in BMC Oral Health that access through the vestibule makes dissection easier and the technique less technique-sensitive. In their systematic review of 14 studies, where VISTA was combined with different materials, six studies reported complete root coverage, and the overall proportion was 58% (95% confidence interval (CI) 49% to 68%) after 6–18 months. This figure applies across the materials, the review has no independent group with porcine collagen matrix, and three of the randomized trials had a high risk of bias.5

For the choice of material, this means that the review does not say anything about VISTA with a porcine matrix alone. For the vestibular access and tunneling, there is an instrument set for VISTA. The procedure itself depends on the defect and is learned through practical training.

Soft tissue augmentation around implants

The porcine acellular dermal matrix is also used to increase the width of keratinized mucosa and the thickness of the soft tissue around implants. Dadlani reviews several cohort studies where the matrix increased both width and thickness, but also shrank during the first year, and several of the studies had no control group. In the one controlled clinical study Dadlani reviews, connective tissue graft provided more volume and thickness after 6 months.1 The evidence for this indication therefore rests on smaller studies. For bone augmentation, see guided bone regeneration.

What do the studies of mucoderm show?

mucoderm® is a porcine acellular dermal matrix from botiss, and it has been used in several of the randomized trials that the meta-analyses above are based on.

Elbana et al. compared mucoderm with connective tissue graft, both placed with a modified coronally advanced tunnel technique for isolated recessions of the RT1 type.3

Study
Elbana et al., BMC Oral Health, 2025
Design
Randomized clinical trial
Participants
40 patients, 20 in each group, isolated RT1 recessions
Follow-up
6 months
  • 96.75% average root coverage with mucoderm after 6 months
  • 97.08% average root coverage with connective tissue graft after 6 months

The difference in root coverage was not statistically significant. The width of keratinized and attached gingiva, attachment level, pocket depth, or aesthetic scores also did not differ significantly between the groups. Gingival thickness, however, was significantly greater in the connective tissue graft group after 6 months. The authors conclude that the matrix can be used as an alternative to connective tissue graft, and they themselves point out the limitations: few patients, short follow-up, and only isolated RT1 recessions, and they call for trials at multiple centers. The trial was designed to find a difference in root coverage, not to show that the materials are equivalent.3

Overall, the trials point toward connective tissue graft when follow-up is longer. In the Koppolu analysis, mucoderm was included in eight of the 16 trials, and all seven trials in the analysis's group for porcine acellular dermal matrix used mucoderm, so the group's results are the results for mucoderm. After 12 months, where the comparison rested on at most four of the seven trials, connective tissue graft provided on average 11.63 percentage points more root coverage (95% CI 7.34 to 15.92), 0.3 mm greater attachment gain, and 0.24 mm more keratinized tissue. The chance of complete root coverage was not statistically significantly different, either after 6 months (relative risk (RR) 0.82; 95% CI 0.66 to 1.02) or after 12 months (RR 0.86; 95% CI 0.72 to 1.01), but both estimates pointed toward connective tissue graft. Gingival thickness was not statistically significantly different between the matrix and connective tissue graft in the overall analysis, in contrast to the Elbana trial, where the gingiva was thicker with connective tissue graft.2

Clinical perspective. Connective tissue graft provides the most root coverage in the meta-analyses and remains the reference treatment. mucoderm has provided root coverage in randomized trials without an additional surgical site in the palate and can therefore be considered when the patient wishes to avoid tissue harvesting, or when more recessions need to be covered than the palate can provide tissue for. The trials do not show that the materials are equivalent: After 12 months, root coverage was on average 11.63 percentage points lower than with connective tissue graft, in the Elbana trial the gingiva was thicker with connective tissue graft, and the authors call for trials with longer follow-up. The choice depends on the clinician's assessment of the defect and the patient's wishes.1, 2, 3

Materials and instruments for soft tissue augmentation

  • Package with mucoderm acellular dermal collagen matrix from botiss

    mucoderm®

    Porcine acellular dermal collagen matrix for recession coverage and soft tissue augmentation.

    See mucoderm® →
  • Instrument set for VISTA tunnel technique

    VISTA instruments

    Instrument set for loosening the periosteum and forming the tunnel through a vestibular access.

    See the VISTA instruments →
  • Angled spoon microsurgical blade from MJK Instruments

    MJK spoon blade SB002

    Angled microsurgical blade for intrasulcular incisions and tunneling.

    See spoon blade SB002 →
See all sizes of mucoderm

Webinars on collagen matrix and soft tissue

botiss has recorded webinars with clinicians who use the material. Here are three that deal with soft tissue augmentation without connective tissue from the palate. They are available at botiss and require a free botissPLUS login.

Cover image for the webinar 6 key uses for mucoderm® in implant dentistry: a clinical webinar
6 key uses for mucoderm® in implant dentistry: a clinical webinar, Dr. Hassan Maghaireh (UK). Dr. Hassan Maghaireh reviews six clinical applications of mucoderm® in implant treatment. The focus is on the soft tissue contour around implants. Watch the webinar at botiss
Cover image for the webinar Beyond the Palate: Achieving Predictable Soft Tissue Volume Without a Second Surgical Site
Beyond the Palate: Achieving Predictable Soft Tissue Volume Without a Second Surgical Site, Dr. Giorgio Tabanella (Italy). Dr. Giorgio Tabanella reviews soft tissue augmentation around teeth and implants without connective tissue from the palate. He uses mucoderm® instead of a connective tissue graft. Watch the webinar at botiss
Cover image for the webinar Boosting soft tissue regeneration: Using mucoderm® in periodontal plastic surgery
Boosting soft tissue regeneration: Using mucoderm® in periodontal plastic surgery, Prof. Giovanni Zucchelli (Italy). Prof. Giovanni Zucchelli reviews the use of mucoderm® in periodontal plastic surgery. Watch the webinar at botiss
View all webinars on biomaterials

Frequently asked questions about collagen matrix

What is the difference between a collagen matrix and a connective tissue graft?

A connective tissue graft is the patient's own tissue, harvested from the palate. A collagen matrix is a processed collagen material, typically from pigs, so an additional surgical site is not required. In a meta-analysis of 16 randomized trials, connective tissue grafts provided greater root coverage after 12 months, while pain was lower with the substitute material in each of the trials, according to the authors; however, the measurements could not be pooled statistically.2

What is mucoderm?

mucoderm is a porcine acellular dermal matrix from botiss. It is made from porcine dermis that has been cleared of cells and non-collagenous proteins, leaving a matrix of type I and III collagen and elastin.1 In a randomized trial involving 40 patients, the mean root coverage after 6 months was 96.75% with mucoderm and 97.08% with connective tissue grafts, with no statistically significant difference.3

What is the VISTA technique?

VISTA stands for vestibular incision subperiosteal tunnel access. It is a tunnel technique in which access is gained through a vertical incision in the vestibule, and the gingiva is detached subperiosteally and advanced coronally while preserving the papillae. In a systematic review by Zhu et al., six of the 14 studies reported complete root coverage, and the overall proportion was 58% when VISTA was combined with different materials.5

Can a collagen matrix be used with the tunnel technique?

Yes, this has been studied. In the study by Elbana et al., mucoderm was placed using a modified coronally advanced tunnel technique.3 A meta-analysis of five randomized trials found no statistically significant difference between the tunnel technique and CAF, but the quality of evidence was very low.4 Mayta-Tovalino et al. and Koppolu et al. also discuss earlier meta-analyses that found better results with CAF than with the tunnel technique when a substitute material was used.2, 4

Are the results with a collagen matrix stable over time?

There are few long-term studies. In the meta-analysis by Koppolu et al., the differences compared with connective tissue grafts in root coverage, attachment level, and keratinized tissue were significant after 12 months, but not after 6 months, and the authors call for longer studies.2 Dadlani describes a case series of 9 patients without a control group, where root coverage after four years was significantly lower than after 12 months, but still higher than before treatment.1

Interests

We disclose the authors' and Puredent's interests so that you can assess the sources yourself.

  • Sources 1 to 6: The authors declare in all six publications that they have no conflicts of interest.
  • Puredent distributes the porcine acellular dermal matrix reviewed in source 1 and used in source 3 and in eight of the trials in source 2. Puredent also sells instruments and microsurgical blades for the tunnel technique.
  • The webinars were produced by the manufacturer of the matrix. They were not used as sources in the article.

Sources

  1. Dadlani S. Porcine Acellular Dermal Matrix: An Alternative to Connective Tissue Graft: A Narrative Review. International Journal of Dentistry. 2021;2021:1652032. DOI
  2. Koppolu P, ElHaddad SA, Abushama AA, et al. Comparative Effectiveness of Autogenous Connective Tissue Grafts and Xenogeneic Soft Tissue Substitutes for Multiple Gingival Recessions: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis. Medicina. 2026;62(2):366. DOI
  3. Elbana A, Saleh W, Youssef J. Comparing Connective Tissue Grafts and Collagen Matrix in Modified Coronally Advanced Tunnel Technique for RT1 Gingival Recession: A Randomized Controlled Clinical Trial. BMC Oral Health. 2025;25:893. DOI
  4. Mayta-Tovalino F, Barboza JJ, Pasupuleti V, Hernandez AV. Efficacy of Tunnel Technique (TUN) versus Coronally Advanced Flap (CAF) in the Management of Multiple Gingival Recession Defects: A Meta-Analysis. International Journal of Dentistry. 2023;2023:8671484. DOI
  5. Zhu Q, Sun F, Gao Y, et al. Clinical efficacy of vestibular incision subperiosteal tunnel access (VISTA) for the treatment of gingival recession: a systematic review and meta-analysis. BMC Oral Health. 2025;25:1497. DOI
  6. Panda S, Khijmatgar S, Arbildo-Vega H, et al. Stability of biomaterials used in adjunct to coronally advanced flap: A systematic review and network meta-analysis. Clinical and Experimental Dental Research. 2022;8(1):421-438 (online 2021). DOI